Carrier Comfort™ Series 95 – 59SC5 Review

Square Footage	Furnace BTU
1,000-1,200 sq. ft. Home	40,000 - 60,000 BTU
1,200-1,500 sq. ft. Home	60,000 BTU
1,500-1,800 sq. ft. Home	60,000 - 80,000 BTU
1,800-2,500 sq. ft. Home	80,000 - 100,000 BTU
2,500-3,500 sq. ft. Home	100,000 to 120,000 BTU

Carrier Comfort™ 95 – 59SC5 Review

The Carrier Comfort™ 95 – 59SC5 is one of Carrier’s most budget-friendly furnace models — an ideal choice for homeowners looking for a reliable, high-efficiency heating system at an affordable price. Despite being a single-stage furnace, it achieves an impressive AFUE rating of up to 96.5%, making it one of the most efficient options in its category.

If you’re considering a furnace upgrade, this detailed review of the Comfort 95 covers everything you need to know — from its key features and specifications to warranty coverage, average prices, and comparisons with other Carrier models — so you can make an informed decision.

About the Comfort™ 95 – 59SC5

Average Installed Price: $3,800 – $4,800

Top Features

Multi-speed ECM blower motor for consistent performance and improved energy efficiency
Secondary heat exchanger captures extra heat to minimize energy waste
Hot surface ignition system provides reliable starts and reduces fuel usage
Quiet operation thanks to sound-insulated design
ENERGY STAR® certified high-efficiency performance
Compatible with Carrier’s Hybrid Heat® technology and ComfortFan™ system
Customizable FCT motor settings for optimal performance during installation
Works seamlessly with ecobee thermostats
Durable build with minimal maintenance requirements
Standard Carrier warranty coverage included

The Bottom Line

The Comfort 95 – 59SC5 is an affordable, entry-level model that delivers solid performance and long-term value. While it doesn’t offer the advanced features of Carrier’s premium models, it includes several efficient technologies that make it a smart investment for smaller homes or regions with milder winters.

With its multi-speed ECM blower motor, dual heat exchangers, and sealed combustion system, this furnace operates quietly and efficiently. It’s designed to reduce energy consumption and enhance home comfort without the higher cost of modulating or two-stage models.

Carrier furnaces are known for their quality and reliability, and the Comfort 95 continues that legacy — offering dependable heating, low noise levels, and a design that can help reduce your monthly utility bills. Its ENERGY STAR® certification also means it may qualify for local energy rebates, helping offset its initial cost.

In-Depth Review

Product Specifications

Specification	Details
AFUE	96.5%
Burner Type	Single-stage
Blower Type	Multi-speed ECM
ENERGY STAR® Certified	Yes
Installed Price Range	$3,800 – $4,800

Features Overview

The Comfort 95 – 59SC5 is designed to provide efficient, dependable heating through two high-quality heat exchangers:

A primary aluminized steel heat exchanger, built for durability and long-term reliability.
A secondary heat exchanger, which extracts additional heat from exhaust gases to improve performance and efficiency.

Thanks to its sealed combustion system and insulated cabinet, the furnace maintains quiet operation — an appealing feature for homeowners who value a peaceful indoor environment.

The multi-speed ECM blower motor not only enhances comfort but also improves overall system efficiency. When paired with a compatible cooling system, it helps boost the system’s SEER rating, offering savings throughout both heating and cooling seasons.

Additionally, this model supports Carrier’s Hybrid Heat® system, allowing you to pair it with an electric heat pump for a dual-fuel setup. The system automatically alternates between electric and gas heating depending on which is more energy-efficient at the time.

Other Key Highlights

Available in multiple capacities to suit different home sizes
Convertible from natural gas to propane
Rugged heavy-gauge steel cabinet protects internal components
Compatible with the Constant ON mode for customizable fan-speed control
Equipped with Carrier’s PowerHeat™ hot surface ignition for consistent, fuel-saving performance
Fully insulated heating compartment for quieter operation and better heat retention

Warranty Coverage

The Carrier Comfort 95 – 59SC5 includes:

Lifetime heat exchanger warranty
10-year limited parts warranty

To receive full warranty benefits, homeowners must register the unit within 90 days of installation. If registration is not completed, the heat exchanger warranty reduces to 20 years, and the parts warranty shortens to 5 years.

Additionally, Carrier requires professional installation by a licensed HVAC technician for the warranty to remain valid.

Comparable Carrier Models

1. Model Comparison by Price

Comfort 95 – 59SC5 vs. Performance™ 96 – 59TP6

For homeowners wondering how much a Carrier furnace costs in Canada, the Performance™ 96 – 59TP6 sits in the mid-range, with prices typically between $5,000 and $5,600 installed.

While the Performance 96 costs more, it includes a two-stage burner and variable-speed blower motor, providing smoother temperature control, better humidity management, and improved airflow — ideal for larger homes or those seeking enhanced comfort.

Both furnaces share a 96.5% AFUE, meaning they deliver similar energy savings. However, the Performance 96 offers superior comfort and temperature consistency for the higher price.

2. Model Comparison by Features

Comfort 95 – 59SC5 vs. Infinity® 98 with Greenspeed® Intelligence (59MN7)

The Infinity® 98 – 59MN7 is Carrier’s most advanced and premium model. It features a modulating burner and variable-speed blower motor, allowing it to adjust heating output in tiny increments to perfectly match your home’s needs.

With a 98.5% AFUE rating, the Infinity 98 delivers the best efficiency in Carrier’s lineup, along with ultra-quiet operation, superior humidity control, and full compatibility with Carrier’s Infinity System Control — unlocking Greenspeed® Intelligence for adaptive comfort and maximum savings.

While both the Infinity 98 and Comfort 95 are efficient, the Infinity’s added technology comes at a significantly higher price point. For homeowners prioritizing cost-effectiveness and reliability over cutting-edge features, the Comfort 95 remains a practical choice.

3. Model Comparison by Tier

Comfort 95 – 59SC5 vs. Comfort™ 92 – 59SC2

The Comfort 92 – 59SC2 is another entry-level option but with a much lower 92.1% AFUE rating and no ENERGY STAR® certification. As a result, it won’t deliver the same energy savings or heating performance as the Comfort 95.

Additionally, furnaces below 95% AFUE no longer meet the Canadian government’s minimum efficiency standards, meaning the Comfort 92 is not recommended — or even available — for most Canadian homes.

For homeowners seeking an affordable, high-efficiency furnace that meets all modern standards, the Comfort 95 – 59SC5 clearly offers better performance, value, and long-term savings.

✅ In Summary:
The Carrier Comfort™ 95 – 59SC5 is a dependable, energy-efficient furnace designed for homeowners seeking solid performance on a budget. It combines Carrier’s proven reliability with high-efficiency operation, quiet performance, and compatibility with modern smart thermostats.

If you’re looking for a cost-effective, ENERGY STAR®-certified furnace that delivers consistent comfort and long-term value, the Comfort 95 – 59SC5 is one of the best entry-level options in Carrier’s lineup.